I was preparing a story about the man who married sisters when I noticed the FamilySearch Shared Tree has given him a guesswork grandmother.
The nine children of Mary THOMPSON shown here can only rustle up one source between them – and that is a census. Had the contributors of this oddball brood sought evidence of their arrival in the vale of tears, they would have discovered that four began life in the body of another woman. And the genetic material to make the other five was donated by a different John CARTER.
John of the screenshot has two sources – both noting his baptism in Flamborough. Just before Christmas 1845 he married Mary STEPHENSON.
Marriages Dec 1845
CARTER John & STEPHENSON Mary, Bridlington 23 43.
Mary S. was born in Ulrome in 1824 to William and Hannah. She gave birth to five sons, the first four boys in the screenshot above and poor Robert, who lived for just a few weeks.
Mary T. first saw light in Kexby, almost forty miles inland from Ulrome. She married her John in York.
Marriages Mar 1846
CARTER John & THOMPSON Mary, York 23 677.
This chap worked as a “railway labourer” and the couple started their family in York. The births of Hannah, Edward and Thompson were registered in Malton.
Given the lack of care in putting this misleading family unit together, I do not have any qualms about attempting to set the records straight.